Cost of Goods Deductibility

Deduction for cost of goods sold limited to negotiated discount price IRS concluded in this ILM that the step transaction doctrine applied to the repayment to companies of the difference between the full list price of merchandise and the negotiated discount price, and therefore the companies’ deduction for cost of goods sold (COGS) was limited to the negotiated price.

Facts. U.S. companies paid the full list price for merchandise and were reimbursed for the difference between the full list price and the negotiated discount price.

IRS analysis. The Service concluded that this transaction met all three tests applied by the courts in determining whether the step transaction doctrine should be invoked:

(1) The end-result test. (2) The mutual interdependence test. (3) The binding commitment test.

Under the end-result test, separate transactions will be combined into a single transaction when it appears that each step was a part of a single transaction. The Service determined that this transaction satisfied the end-result test because the payment by the companies of the full list price was a component part of a single transaction that included the repayment of the difference between the full list price and the negotiated discount price. The Service noted that all of the parties involved knew the price of each item on the day the order was placed, and the ordering system was put in place to induce the companies to place more centralized orders. Because the companies understood that their actual COGS would be the negotiated discount price, not the list price, the end-result test was satisfied.

The mutual interdependence test concentrates on the relationship between the steps (i.e., the steps so interdependent that the legal relations created by one step would have been fruitless without a completion of the series). The IRS concluded that the companies would not have paid full list price for the merchandise without knowing that they would be repaid and the true price would be the negotiated discount price. Therefore, the transaction satisfied the mutual interdependence test.

The third test requires that there be a binding commitment to take the later steps. The Service determined that the application of the step transaction doctrine was warranted because the companies were provided with price lists that they relied on when ordering and if they didn’t receive the repayments as promised, they would have had legal standing to compel payment.

Because the step transaction doctrine applied, the companies could not deduct as COGS the full list price of the merchandise ordered, but were limited to the negotiated discount price.

Implications. The payment by the companies of full list price, followed by the receipt by the companies of a rebate (so as to reflect that the true cost to the companies of the merchandise was the negotiated price), apparently represented transactions that were closed rather than transactions that were still open. Had the right to the rebate, or the amount thereof, been in some way unknown or contingent, which was not the case here, the companies likely would have reported income from the rebate, reflecting that the companies understated income previously by overstating COGS. It is clear, based on the application of any of the tests under the step transaction doctrine, that both the right to, and the amount of, the rebate owed to the companies was established with certainty.

While the facts do not indicate why the inter-company transaction provisions of the consolidated return Regulations were implicated, the memorandum provides a useful, although brief, description of the three alternative tests under the step transaction doctrine and reminds taxpayers that satisfaction of any one of the three tests is sufficient for the step transaction doctrine to apply.

Tax Problems? We resolve all tax problems and negotiate tax settlements to lower your tax liability.

Client Reviews
Mike has given us peace of mind! He helped negotiate down a large balance and get us on a payment plan that we can afford with no worries! The stress of dealing with the IRS is huge and Mike helped us through it all. The peace of mind is invaluable, thank you Mike!April S.
Mike Habib - Thank you for being so professional and honest and taking care of my brothers IRS situation. We are so relieved it is over and the offer in compromise process went just as you said. Mike is very professional and will give you honest answers to the OIC process and you can really trust him. You won't be sorry you chose him!Joe and Deborah V.
Mike is a true professional. He really came thru for me and my business. Dealing with the IRS is very scary. I'm a small business person who works hard and Mike helped me see that they are not that scary after all. He was always there with the answers I needed and was very good about calling me back which I appreciated since your first reaction is to freak out and ask a million questions. He solved a messy case and worked very hard to resolve it. His rates are VERY reasonable for the amount of work he does! I give him my highest recommendation!Marcie R.
Mike was incredibly responsive to my IRS issues. Once I decided to go with him (after interviewing numerous other tax professionals), he got on the phone with the IRS immediately (as in the same day I signed with him) to squash an impending issue. And he worked directly with them to quickly come to a resolution I am very happy with. I'd highly recommend reaching out to Mike to see if he can help you with any IRS issues. I'm very satisfied!Marshall W.
I’ve seen and heard plenty of commercials on TV and radio for businesses offering tax help. I did my research on many of them only to discover numerous complaints and unresolved tax issues. I found Mike Habib through my own online search and contacted him. He was very professional with great communication, always answering my questions and concerns. Mike resolved my complicated tax problem just as he said he would. I would definitely recommend his services to family and friends.Nancy & Sal V.
BBB Accredited Business
Trust Link
California Society of Enrolled Agents
Enrolled Agent